Session #96 · 1979–81

Speech #960039663

Mr. Waldheim. about their ability to intercede in this kind of effort and with the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees. As a result of the failure of that policy. we had 135.000 refugees evacuated by us from Vietnam. most of whom came to the United States. Half who got out in that hysteria. probably should not. and we left many back in Vietnam who should have been brought here. And ever since then. our nonpolicy toward Vietnam has contributed to the chaotic and tragic outflow of Indochinese refugees. But while we may regret the past. towards Vietnam has contributed to the refugees are a tragic fact of life. What we are really talking about here is an entirely different issueabout how to cope with this problem. and what our humanitarian responsibilities are. I understand the frustrations of the Senator from Kentucky. We have heard that we have some 4 to 7 million illegal aliens here in the United States at the present timebut no one really knows. We have been unable to deal with that particular issue effectively and efficiently to date. But because of our frustration over that particular issue. it seems to me we are trying to throw out the baby with the bath water. Refugees and illegal aliens are separate issues. As the Senator knows. we have established a Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy and. quite frankly. I do not remember the strong support of many of those. who are most critical about this problem today. supporting the establishment of that Cornmission. We are trying to equip that Commission with funding to deal with the total issue of both illegal aliens and our outdated immigration law. to achieve long overdue immigration reform. The Commission will begin Its important work on We know. Mr. President. that In the coming months. we will have their recommendations. and we will be able to consider those recommcndations in the Judiciary Committeeboth shortterm as well as longerterm recommendations for immigration reform. They must by statute report every 6 months. But we cannot wait until their final report is received to act on refugee resettlement. We cannot ask refugeesSoviet Jews and Indochineseto wait for this longerterm report. What we are asking for now. Mr. President. is maintaining this authorization for refugees at the present level. It reflects our understanding of the recent pattern of refugee movement in Southeast Asia and Eastern Europe. The fact is that it is extremely difficult to predict with any degree of certainty what the problems of refugees are going to be what their numbers are going to be. Refugees by definition are hard to predict. It would be nice to set an absolute figure. but it is very difficult to do that. In the refugee bill we have built a figure of 50.000 normal flow refugees. based upon what have been the average flow lines of the past two decades. But there is an emergency provision to bring in more. Everyone understands that before the moneys are going to be appropriated. either now or under the proposed bill. we are going to have to come to the Appropriations Committee to ask for appropriations and prove the need. Mr. President. this amendment also ignores that the Congress has acted to stimulate refugee movement and free migration. The U.S. Senate has gone on record as saying that we want to encourage. for example. the Soviet Union to carry out a program of reunification of families. freedom of emigration. and elimination of persecutions. that we will terminate mostfavorednation trade status with them unless they are going to facilitate the reunification of families and promote freedom of movement. However. the effect of this amendment. that is offered by my colleague from South Carolina and my colleague from Kentucky. is to say "You cannot do that because we are going to close our immigration door to refugees by cutting the authorization for refugee resettlement." It makes no sense from a policy point of view. Finally. Mr. President. I would just underline the points that have been made by the Senator from Maryand and the Senator from New York. We haveI personally have. and members of the administration havebeen meeting with ambassadors from foreign countries urging them to take on additional "boat people" and other refugees. I talked with Ambassador Togo of Japan. and only recently we have seen a rather important statement by the Japanese and a significant changing of their attitude. They are contributing more to the UNHCR program in Indochina than we are. We are seeing similar attitudes and similar statements by foreign ministers and prime ministers of other countries. There is concrete action taking place today. Both France and Australia are ahead of us in resettling Indochinese refugees since 1975. in terms of per capita population. At a time when we are trying to get other countries. particularly European and Latin American countries. to help financially. to accept refugees. we are by this amendment effectively reducing the efforts of the United States. It makes no sense. Mr. President. I have indicated to the Senator from Kentucky that we are willing to work closely with him in developing the refugee bill. and on immigration reform. We know he has been concerned about these issues. as has the Senator from South Carolina. But those are longer term questions. It seems to me what we are attempting to do here is to make the best judgment now. based upon recent developments. as to what the flow of refugees will be next year. In 1976. 1977. and 1978. the numbers have moved from about 50.000. 80.000. to 120.000. and what we are effectively doing is saying we hope it will be less. but it probably will not. This authorization represents prudent budgetary planning for the worst. not best of worldswhich is what one must do in helping refugees. We are preparing legislation to try to deal with the longer term problem. But let us not now reduce or eliminate the authorization for next year when we are faced with the current realities. and prior to the time the committees themselves have had a chance to deal with this in a responsible manner.
Keywords matched
Refugees Immigration Refugee emigration immigration refugees refugeesSoviet illegal aliens refugee

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Soviet Jews
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
EDWARD KENNEDY
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
MA
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
960039663
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →