Some see it as a positive contribution while others see it as a definite negative factor. However. we do know by way of comparison that 6 million people presently are unemployed in this country and that in 1978 the Federal Government spent approximately $9 billion on job creation programs. Although it would be simplistic to state that every illegal alien takes a job that a legal resident or citizen could fill. the magnitude of the numbers involved requires that we view the matter as an extremely critical situation. The legal side of our immigration program is also a cause of great. concern. Problems and inconsistencies are constantly cropping up. Although we set an annual quota of 290.000 immigrants. we in fact admitted well over 400.000 in 1978. A recent report by the General Accounting Office revealed that thousands of the legal immigrants who come to this country each year. become immediate recipients of supplemental security income payments. The estimated cost of this is approximately $75 million per year. a conservative estimate according to GAO. Even our system of keeping track of legal aliens is inadequate to meet the demands placed upon it. When the INS was asked by the Attorney General to report on how many Iranian students are in this country following recent student disturbances. the INS was forced to admit that its antiquated system could not provide the answer. In fact. the effectiveness of the operation of the INS has been called to question so many times that the Attorney General has appointed a special task force of the Department of Justice to investigate the overall administration of the INS. Even though the INS is facing the impossible task of trying to deal with the flood of illegal aliens and to meet the demands created by the flow of legal immigrants with inadequate resources. the administration has requested in its budget for fiscal year 1980 a reduction in manpower for the INS. The lack of wisdom and foresight in this decision is obvious. Yet. it is an accurate reflection of the general lack of direction our immigration problems are receiving. An integral part of our national immigration program is the admission of individuals who are classified as refugees. It is in this area that we have suffered the greatest loss of congressional control. The procedures we are now using for admitting refugees are in urgent need of change. because they have not been formally approved by the whole Congress and are primarily an ad hoe creation of the executive branch. Under the immigration laws of this country a quota of 17.400 refugees per year is authorized. Yet in recent years this quota has been substantially exceeded through the use of the vague "parole authority" granted to the U.S. Attorney General. Under this procedure the Attorney General has sole discretion to decide how many refugees he will admit at any given time. The result is that we are admitting hundreds of thousands of refugees without an enforceable quota and without the benefit of guidelines formulated by Congress. The present use of the "parole authority" obviously exceeds the original intent of the authorizing statute. This intent was clearly reiterated in 1965 when the Immigration and Nationality Act was substantially altered. The congressional report on that legislation stated: Inasmuch as definite provision has now been made for refugees. it Is the express intent of the committee that the parole provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act. which remain unchanged by this bill. be administered in accordance with the original intenticn of the drafters of that legislation. The parole provisions were designed to authorize the Attorney General to act only in emergent. individual. and Isolated situations. such as the case of an alien who requires immediate medical attention. and not for the immigration of classes or groups outside of the limit of the law. Obviously Attorney General Bell and previous Attorneys General agree with this assessment. In testimony submitted by Attorney General Bell to the House Judiciary Committee on November 28. 1978. he stated: I am not comfortable about the use of the parole authority In these nor any other group situations where I have exercised that authority in the past. Nor is this discomfort unique to me. Every Attorney General before me. faced with such requests. has voiced similar reservations because the intent of the Congress. in establishing the parole authority. was to provide a safety valve for unusual. individual cases of compelling need that could not otherwise be met. It was not to provide the means to endrun the other provisions of the immigration law. Admittedly. the Congress acquiesced to a limited extent in these actions. However. the increasing frequency and the magnitude of the Attorney General paroles must compel us to put a stop to the procedure which has the chief law enforcement officer of the United States stating publicly that he is "endrunning" the immigation laws. The Attorney General stated on March 26. 1979. that he was exercising his "parole authority" again in order to admit an additional 60.000 refugees between May and October of 1979. These oneman decisions will result in 108.000 refugees being admitted in 1979. It will also mean that approximately 250.000 Indochinese will have been admitted since 1975 under this same vague authority. I have written to the Attorney General on two occasions advising that the continued use of his "parole authority" was inappropriate at this time for four reasons. First. as I stated previously. his "parole authority" was never intended by Congress to be used to admit large numbers of immigrants into the country. It was intended by Congress to be used only for individual and unique cases. Second. Congress presently has under active consideration a bill which would establish a formalized procedure for admitting refugees beyond a specified quota. For the Attorney General to proceed with additional largescale paroles at a time when Congress is in the process of formulating refugee legislation. which will hopefully reflect a national immigration policy. borders on being an intrusion on Congressional prerogatives in this matter. To delay additional admissions at this crucial time would in no way reflect unfavorably upon the United States. our generosity toward the homeless of the world is well known and it far exceeds the efforts of any other nation. To date. we as a nation have provided more financial assistance and have taken in more refugees than any other nation. Our commitment to humanitarian needs has been translated into positive action while other nations which have the resources to contribute a great deal actually give very little. A prime example of this is Japan. which is a prosperous nation with very close ties to other Asian nations. However. Japan has only admitted three Indochinese refugees. Recently. after strong pressure. Japan agreed to admit several hundred refugees into the country. This is a commitment which is welcome but nonetheless extremely late. Third. Congress made the decision last year to treat our immigration policy in a comprehensive fashion when we created the Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy. This select commission. which has now been formed. was given the responsibility of examining our immigration policy. including our refugee admissions. In its authorizing legislation the commission is specifically instructed to make "a comprehensive review of the provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act and make legislative recommendations" and to "assess the social. economic. political. and demographic impact of previous refugee programs and review the criteria for. and numerical limitations on. the admission of refugees to the United States." The millions of immigrants. including refugees. who are coming into our country each year. have the potential to create pressures which could cause our country serious problems in the years ahead. Zero population growth estimates that if we assume there is a net immigration of illegal aliens of 800.000 per year. along with our legal immigration. the population of the United States 20 years from now will be 25 million more than without illegal immigration. The impact that this increased population will have on scarce energy resources. governmental services. employment. housing. and many other necessities is staggering and demonstrates very graphically why we can no longer deal with the immigration issue in a piecemeal fashion. This is why it is imperative that we discontinue our ad hoc approaches to the problem and concentrate on the total immigration issue which includes legal immigrants. illegal aliens. and refugees. If we continue to blindly ignore the consequences of our actions or inactions on the immigration issue. we will feel the full impact within a very short period of time. The various problems associated with increased immigration were clearly spelled out by a report prepared by the Environmental Coalition earlier this year. In this report it was projected that if present trends continue illegal immigration will add 40 million to our population by the year 2000. Using this as the basis for their computations the fund estimated thatBy 1990. the extra oil required to meet the needs for an additional 20 million American residents will be 1.2 billion barrels. to be imported at a cost to the U.S. of $16.4 billion. This cost figure was arrived at before the recent round of oil price hikes by the producing nations. which means that the ultimate cost will be substantially more. Given our present concern about our dependence on foreign oil and the worsening energy shortage. any decision which results in increasing the U.S. population should be carefully weighed against the resulting increased energy demands. An example of the type of immigration pressures we face can be found in Mexico. Sixty percent of the illegal aliens who come to the United States come from Mexico. Their unemployment is already well into the doubledigit area and their population will double by the year 2000. Even with the new wealth which is anticipated to be made available by their vast oil deposits. it is believed by reliable sources that their unemployment situation will not improve for the next 20 years. With the population information we have available now. we can reasonably predict that the pressure to emigrate from Mexico and other developing countries will continue to increase. In the area of refugees. the situation is just as gloomy. There is still a steady flow out of Indochina. This is adding to the present worldwide pool of refugees or displaced persons. which totals approximately 13 million. Recent developments such as those in Iran threaten to contribute to the overall problem. The office of the U.S. Coordinator of Refugee Affairs accurately summed up the situation when it stated in its 1979 world refugee assessment: The world refugee population today exceeds that of any period in recent history. Refugees were generated in Africa and Southeast Asia at a substantially higher rate in 1978 than in 1977. This rate of flow will probably continue and. for some African groups. could increase dramatically in the months ahead. To proceed with largescale admissions may impose upon us a commitment which the select commission may find to be inappropriate. However. once that commitment has been made. it will be impossible for us to go back and correct it. It seems that the logical approach would be to wait until we do know the answers to many of our questions before blindly moving ahead. The fourth reason why we must be extremely concerned about our refugee policy is the cost factor. Given the mood of the American taxpayers today. I do not believe that they are willing to continue to support a program of the magnitude we have entered into under the Attorney Generals "parole authority." President Carter has told the American people that the Federal Government can no longer continue to expand deficit spending in an effort to meet all the needs of the American public. He stated in his 1980 budget message that. in order to continue to support those programs that represent only our most pressing needs. he has "terminated. reduced. or deferred other programs." I do not believe that we as elected officials can tell the American taxpayer that vitally important domestic programs will have to be reduced or terminated while continuing to follow a policy that will require billions of dollars to be spent over the coming years on an openended immigration program. a program which is obviously growing and not diminishing. as are some vital domestic programs. Over the last 25 years. we have spent $1.3 billion on the Cuban refugee assistance program. which is still operating. even though the number of incoming Cuban refugees substantially declined many years ago. Our experience with a more recent program is proving to be even costlier. Since 1975. we have spent approximately $1 billion on the Indochinese refugee assistance program and the end still is not in sight. It is estimated that total expenditures for refugee programs for 1980 will be approximately $500 million. assuming an admission level of 124.000. It is almost impossible to find the total costs involved. because they are often hidden in nonrefugee programs such as food stamps. The largest part of these expenditures for 1980 will come from admitting and resettling refugees. However. this projected admission level could be increased if the Attorney General decides to do so. Although the immediate and direct costs of our refugee program are fairly apparent. wc still have little or no solid data on what the indirect costs will be in either the short or long range. We do not know what this increase in population will mean insofar as demands on governmental services or resources in general are concerned. Our facts at this time are extremely sketchy. On the positive side. we do know that the employment rate for refugees is extremely high. However. many appear to be underemployed. because approximately onethird of the Indochinese are still receiving governmental assistance. While the high employment rate for refugees is encouraging. we still do not know how this affects our domestic pool of 6 million unemployed or the billions we are spending to create jobs. Nor do we know what significance this will have for the economy if we experience a recession in late 1979. as many economists are predicting. As a free nation we should not be ashamed of setting out to formulate a rational and comprehensive immigration policy which is in the best interests of our citizens. Each nation has the inherent right to protect the integrity of its borders and regulate the flow of immigration. and the United States should not be an exception to this universally accepted practice. Even Mexico. which has benefitted substantially from the emigration of its unemployed citizens to the United States. is rumored to be devising better ways to secure its Southern borders from immigrants who will be attracted by the economic activity generated by their new oil money. Canada. which is similar to the United States in its land area and its history of being a land of opportunity for immigrants. completely revamped its immigration laws last year. The new immigration law contains provisions relating immigration to labor market needs and longterm planning for the size. rate of growth. and geographic distribution of the population. Mr. President. I am not advocating an isolationist policy which attempts to close our doors to all immigration. We can and should have an active immigration policy in the United States. I firmly believe that it is healthy for our country to have an infusion of new blood on a regular basis and that we have a moral duty to assist the homeless of the world in every reasonable fashion. However. we must have a total immigration policy which is as fair to American citizens as it is to immigrants. We will never accomplish this as long as we continue deciding immigration questions in a piecemeal fashion and without adequate information on the ultimate consequences. At this time. we have no real understanding of the economic. social. political. or demographic impact of present immigration levels. I believe that it is time that we act responsibly on this issue by discovering the facts before we continue down a road with so many potential pitfalls. Once we have traveled this road. it will be impossible to retrace our steps.
Keywords matched
Refugees illegal alien Immigration Refugee emigration emigrate immigration immigrants illegal immigration illegal aliens refugees refugee