Session #95 · 1977–79

Speech #950394225

Call this cultureH. It is a degree of pluralism in cultureH that we want to encourage. Immigrants who come here to escape grinding poverty bring (by definition) a standard load of cultureA. but most of them (in fact) bring precious little cultureH. They should not be blamed: this deficiency is just one of the consequences of poverty. But how much will the immigrants retention of their cultureH. or their acquisition of a new cultureH. be furthered by excusing them from learning English? Certainly the native majority receives little benefit from the expense of the Voting Rights Act. If we are serious about diminishing the provincialism of the native majority. let us make a working knowledge of at least one foreign language a requirement of citizenship for all. Immigrants should be able to fulfill this requirement more easily than natives. For both groups. language education should be continued until the associated cultureH can be comprehended. Without doubt. such a proposal would be dismissed as utopian. The aim of the Voting Rights Act is probably purely cosmetic. It is an expensive and deceptive cosmetic. The case against unrestricted immigration rests on the fundamental theory of the commons.* A commons is a resource exploited according to the directive of Karl Marx: "From each according to his ability. to each according to his needs." What this means in practice. and why it leads to ruin. can be illustrated in the developing tragedy of the oceanic fisheries. The oceans are open to fishing by all nations. each taking out whatever its abilities permit. as dictated by its needs as it sees them. There is no supranational authority to define the needs or control the actions of each nation.
Identified stereotypes
Immigrants from grinding poverty bring little cultureH.
Keywords matched
immigration immigrants Immigrants

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Cultural threat Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
CLAIR BURGENER
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
950394225
Paragraph
#6
← Prev Next →