Session #95 · 1977–79

Speech #950394225

Let us begin by sweeping several red herrings out of the way. First. I do not assert that immigrants are inferior to citizens. The problem of innate quality is so complicated (and perhaps insoluble) that it is operationally wise to assume an innate equality between immigrants and longtime occupants of a land. The issue discussed here will be co.ncerned with quantity. not quality. Second. I know of no thoughtful person who would (if he could) stop all immigration. The benefits of variety. of periodic fresh Infusions of new peoples. and new ideas are real. No adventurous. lively nation wants to forego them. But how many immigrants are needed to secure these benefits? A thousand per year? Ten thousand? Surely not more. Moreover. if the seasoning of variety is what we desire to secure by immigration. we should discriminate among immigrants. preferentially admitting those who personally embody more of the culture of their homeland rather than those who carry a lesser load: bluntly. we should discriminate in favor of the rich and against the poor. (This would. of course. raise another difficult moral issue. that of the "brain drain.") Adding legal immigrants to the illegals. it appears that the United States is now being invaded by approximately two million immigrants per year. Of all the other sovereign countries in the United Nations. not one is subject to anything like such an invasion. In fact. yearly immigrants into the United States outnumber the immigrants into all other nations combined. To reduce the U.S. immigration rate to a fraction of its present value (as desired by more than threequarters of our citizens) would merely be to bring our country in line with the international norm. But we are a nation of immigrants! How can we slam the door now that we are inside?" True. America is a nation of immigrants. but we are not unique. Every country is a nation of immigrants. often many waves of them. All that varies is the stage of development. Tn the early stages. immigrantsworking bodiesare needed to populate an open country. Ultimately there comes the time when no more bodies are needed. when indeed. further heavy immigration is destructive of national goals. At this point. the descendants of the earlier immigrants had better muster the moral courage to shut the great barn door. To meet temporary labor crises. "guest workers" might be admitted for strictly limited periods now and then. but the inflow should be no more than a trickle. and it should soon be reversed. Citizenship is rigidly rationed by almost every country except the United States.
Keywords matched
immigration immigrants immigrantsworking

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Cultural enrichment Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
CLAIR BURGENER
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
950394225
Paragraph
#4
← Prev Next →