President. one thing emerges clearly from the confusing and conflicting reports from Lebanon. thousands of innocent civiliansLebanese and Palestinianare being killed. Some of this killing is a direct consequence of the battles being Waged. Some of it appears random. Unfortunately some of the killing is occurring because the refugee camps are being deliberately shelled by artillery fire directed at them. The refugee camps have always been centers of political activities and are also arsenals. Nonetheless. the people in these camps. are not combatants and they should not be subject to the bombardment now going on. Both sides should give them a chance to get out. if they want to do so.