Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940263867

Mr. Speaker. I rise today to speak of something which has troubled this Nation for too many years: The problem of illegal aliens. It is a growing problem of staggering proportions. Studies done for the Immigration and Naturalization ServiceINS--indicate that for every 1 million adult illegal aliens in the United States. there is a "presumable net tax burden of roughly $2 billion." Estimating 8 million illegal aliens in this Nation with approximately 80 percent of those being adults. INS projects an annual tax burden of $13 billion or higher. The analysis also projects an increase in the number of illegal aliens by 250.000 per year. adding at least $500 million yearly to the already enormous tax burden. I have devoted considerable thought and attention to this problem. and I urge this Congress to reappraise its current approach so as to effectively curtail the rapidly increasing influx of illegal aliens into this Nation. The point has been made that our present immigration policy is in need of revision and in fact forces many foreigners to use illegal immigration procedures to enter our country. There is currently a 2year wait for visas. which makes work certification almost impossible to obtain. Our policy Is discriminatory against those In our own hemisphere where we have placed a ceiling on total immigration. rather than the more equitable preference system with numerical limitations by countryas exists for immigration from the Eastern Hemisphere. Such an approach might help to reduce future illegal entry into the United States. and I would support the exploration of that avenue. but we must go further and independently address the problem we now face of massive illegal immigration. One of the most popular suggested solutions is to withdraw the possibility of employment for illegal aliensby removing the work incentive. the attraction for illegal immigration is also removed. This was the premise of H.R. 982now H.R. 8713legislation introduced by my colleague. the distinguished chairman of the Judiciary Committee. Representative RODINO. The bill passed the House in both the 92d and 93d Congresses. but failed to be reported out of committee in the Senate. It calls upon an employer to make a bona fide inquiry into a job applicants immigration status. The bill provides a warning for a first offense. a civil fine for the second offense. and larger fine and/or imprisonment for a third offense. While I am sympathetic to the bills intent. I do not believe that it would be effective. We must realize the fact that illegal aliens work for subminimum wages in substandard conditions. a reality which makes the profit motive a real factor for some employers. The penalties in H.R. 982 do not seem to me to present a strong dissuading factor. Furthermore. a bona fide inquiry may merely consist of putting the question verbally or asking the prospective employee to sign a declaration of his legal status. Beside the obvious difficulty of proving how real an effort the employer madeespecially if we must rely on frightened aliens for corroborationit seems more than likely that an alien who has risked his life and violated immigration laws to get into the United States will not truthfully sign the statement of legality. It is also important to consider the threat such a system poses to the civil liberties of minority group members ind especially to foreign looking or sounding Americans who may be called upon to continually reprove their citizenship. It also opens the door for a type of legal discrimination: Prejudiced employers may claim that an applicant appeared to have fradulent documentation. or failed to convince the employer of his citizenship.
Identified stereotypes
Illegal aliens are a tax burden.
Keywords matched
Immigration illegal aliensby Naturalization immigration visas illegal aliens illegal immigration

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
EDWARD KOCH
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
940263867
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →