Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940262192

Mr. Speaker. I am today introducing a comprehensive bill to establish precise and definitive procedures for the admission of refugees into the United States from any country in the world. At the present time. the refugee policy of the United States is formulated primarily by the executive branch with very little meaningful congressional input Into this process. The authority to admit refugees has been delegatedprimarily as a result of congressional inactionentirely to the executive branch. and this parole authority which is granted to the Attorney General under section 212(d) (5) of the Immigration and Nationality Act is extremely ambiguous and far too broad. In effect. the Attorney General has been given blanket authority to parole groups or classes of refugeesinto the United States without the approval of the Congress. It has been the policy and practice of the Attorney General. however. to consult with certain members of the Judiciary Committees of the House and the Senate prior to actually paroling such refugees. but I should emphasize that this consultation is merely the result of custom and tradition not a statutory requirement. In my opinion. the entire procedure is completely arbitrary and because of the many pressures that are brought to bear. it places an undue burden on the handful of members of these committees who are consulted for their views. I clearly recognize that there is a need for a certain degree of administrative flexibility as well as a need for expeditious action when exceptional or emergency refugee situations arise. At the same time. the Congress cannot shirk its basic responsibility to enact meaningful and specific legislation establishing the refugee policy of this country. It is apparent that the current procedures for refugee admission have been developed in an ad hoc fashion. and there is no accountability under these procedures either to the Congress or to the American people. As a result. decisions to admit certain categories of refugees are too often based on: Foreign policy considerations. pressures from special interest groups. or the positions of small numbers of individuals within the execuive branch. or for that matter within the Congress. Mr. Speaker. it was not until 1965 that permanent provisions for the admission of refugees into the United States were incorporated into our immigration law. Even at best this provision. 203(a) (7). of the Immigration and Nationality Act provides for the admission of up to 10.200 refugee entries annually. This provision was inadequate at the outset. arbitrarily drafted. and offered no provision or procedure for the admission into the United States of refugees from emergent. unexpected. or unusual situations. The inadequacy of the provision was demonstrated even before the ink was dry on the act of October 3. 1965 when the late President Lyndon B. Johnson after signing this act. stated. contrary to the legislative history of that act. that the United States would accept all refugees from Cuba who were able to come to the United States. In view of the ambiguity surrounding the scope of the Attorney Generals current parole authority and because of the confused historical usage of this authority. my bill would establish specific procedures and numerical limitations regarding the admission of refugees to this country. First of all. the legislation would provide resettlement opportunities in the United States for the normal flow of persons fleeing political. racial. and religious persecution. Second. my bill establishes separate procedures in order to respond to extraordinary or emergent refugee situations. This section of the bill is premised upon the fact that every effort should be made to Internationalize refugee problems which arise around the world. but it also recognizes that some refugee situations may arise for which the United States has a special responsibility or concern. I believe the provisions of this legislation are entirely consistent with this countrys tradition of respondingwith compassion and concernto refugee situations which have arisen over the years in various parts of the world. We certainly can be most proud of this refugee heritage and at the same time we must insure that our refugee policy is properly developed by the Congress. after thorough and detailed consideration. The Congress can no longer delegateby acquiescencetotal authority to the Attorney General. and I sincerely hope that this legislation will enable Congress to exercise its constitutional responsibilities in this area. The Congress in enacting the comprehensive Immigration and Nationality Act has set forth a detailed scheme for admitting aliens into this country. and we have imposed certain numerical limitations upon such admission. It. therefore. makes little sense to delegate to the Attorney General the ultimate authority to admit persons into this country without any specific guidelines or numerical limitations. In fact. since 1962. approximately 1 million refugees have come to our shores under this extralegal procedure which is approximately onethird of those admitted during this same period under the express limitations of our immigration law. In this regard. I have requested the Department of Justice on numerous occasions over the last 8 months to furnish my Subcommittee on Immigration. Citizenship. and International Law with specific criteria or guidelines governing the future exercise of parole by the Attorney General. I regret to say that the Department has not responded to these repeated requests and it now appears that the Congress must endeavor to legislate these guidelines. The conditions and numerical ceilings set forth in my bill represent a reasonable and humanitarian aproach to this issue and I am hopeful that my bill will receive the wholehearted support of my colleagues. I firmly believe that in extraordinary refugee situations in which the total number of refugees entering the United States could exceed the limits contained in this bill. it is incumbent upon the Congress to enact special legislation. For the benefit of my colleagues. I would like to insert at this point in the RECORD a brief summary of this proposed legislation. SUMMARY or BILL 1. Definition of RefugeeWith slight modifications. the "refugee" definition contained in the proposed bill is almost identical to that which Is contained in the U.N. Convention on the Status of Refugees. The definition simply requires that a person be outside of the country of his nationality or last habitual residence and be unable or unwilling to return to such country because of persecution. or fear of persecution. based on race. religion. nationality. membership of a particular social group or political opinion. 2. Normal Refugee FlowThe proposed bill authorizes the Attorney General to admit 20.000 refugees annually (current law allows the conditional entry of 10.200 refugees from the Eastern Hemisphere who are fleeing from communism or from certain areas of the Middle East). This is designed to cover the usual refugee flow and will remove existing geographical and ideological limitations and extend eligibility for refugee status to natives of the Western Hemisphere. 3. Extraordinary Refugee SituationIn the event of an extraordinary or emergent refugee situation. two procedures are established authorizing the President to admit refugees: (a) In the event of an appealpresumably from the UNHCRthe President may admit 15 percent of the total refugees or 5.000 of such refugees. whichever Is less. The Presidents authority is contingent upon his determination that other countries in the international community will accept for resettlement their fair share of such refugees. (b) In the event of a determination by the President that the United States has a "special concern" or obligation wtih regard to a particular emergent refuge situation. the President is authorized to admit 20.000 such refugees. The Presidents authority under either of the above methods is also contingent upon his consultation with the House and Senate Judiciary Committees and his later written determination to the Congress that the admission of these refugees: (a) will significantly promote the national interest. (b) Is justified by grave humanitarian concerns. and (c) is not possible under the normal refugee provisions. The Presidents authority to admit a particular group of refugees under either of these methods shall be terminated with regard to such refugees in the event of a resolution adopted by either body of the Congress expressly disapproving of the continued exercise of the Presidents authority for that group of refugees. Detailed reports to the Congress are required with regard to all refugees admitted under these two procedures. 4. Adjustment of Status for Refugees--All refugees admitted under either the normal or the extraordinary procedures shall be eligible to have their status adjusted (retroactively to the time of admission) after he has been in the United States for a period of two years. 5. Conforming AmendmentsA variety of technical and conforming amendments are included In the proposed bill. For example. section 203 (a) (7) --seventh preference--is repealed and the percentage of admissions allocated to this category under the preference system (6 percent of total or 10.200) is transferred to the current second preference category (spouses and unmarried sons and daughters of permanent resident aliens) which is already heavily subscribed for many countries.
Keywords matched
Refugees Immigration Refugee immigration RefugeeWith refugees refugee refugeesinto

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOSHUA EILBERG
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
PA
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
940262192
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →