Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940236538

Mr. Speaker. California has become the frontrunner for supporters of a movement to prohibit the employment of illegal aliens in this country. Although the Federal Government has the exclusive power to regulate immigration. the Supreme Court ruled on February 25. 1976. that this does not mean that States are powerless to pass laws concerning the employment of illegal aliens. Thus. California law now makes it illegal for its employers to hire illegal aliens when such action would deny jobs to legal residents. California State legislators have responded to the problem of high unemployment by making a brave and difficult decision to set job priorities for legal citizens. Congress would be wise to improve the Nations unemployment picture by amending the Immigration and Nationality Act to discourage the hiring of illegal aliens. During the past decade. the United States has tolerated the presence of a substantial population of illegal aliens. Currently. officials estimate that betwcan 4 and 12 million persons are residing illegally in the United States. While the number of illegal aliens has been rising steadily. concern over their presence has also grown. primarily because of high unemployment and lessthanprosperous economic conditions on the domestic scene. In other times. this problem of illegal aliens might not have fallen into the public limelight. But it is believed that foreign nationals in the United States occupy an estimated 1 million jobs that would otherwise go to American citizens. A House Judiciary Committee report notes that some 356.000 of these jobs were located in industry. 235.000 in agriculture. and 309.000 in service occupations. Testimony reveals that of the illegal aliens apprehended in six major U.S. cities between January and June 1975. 62.3 percent of those aliens were employed. mainly in industry. Mounting evidence confirms the suspicion that illegal aliens are drawn to this country primarily because of economic opportunities not available in countries of their origin. Thus. signiflcance of the illegal alien problem is measured most often as an economic one. In addition to the adverse impact on jobs. illegal aliens reportedly cost the country millions of dollars in unpaid taxes. plus money spent on detention and deportation. They are considered to be a serious additional burden to the alreadyswollen public assistance rolls. And. because they tend to send considerable amounts of money back to their home countries. their presence here has an ill effect on the U.S. balance of payments. Moreover. the status of illegal aliens makes them subject to serious exploitation on the job. Because they fear discovery. prosecution. or deportation. they have no bargaining position with their employers. Consequently. their employment is often characterized by low wages and a lack of common rights and benefits. Supreme Court Justice Brennan recently summarized the issue this way: Employment of illegal aliens in times of high unemployment deprives citizens and legally admitted aliens of jobs. acceptance by illegal aliens of jobs on substandard terms as to wages and working conditions can seriously depress wage scales and working conditions of citizens and legally admitted aliens and employment of Illegal aliens under such conditions can diminish the effectiveness of labor unions. Clearly. the time is right for the proposed amendment H.R. 8713. which would make it unlawful for U.S. employers or their agents to knowingly hire aliens. This bill could be an effective antidote to the problems created by our illegal alien population. The intention of this legislation is not to close our doors to immigrants. but to eliminate the temptation for illegal entries. Its purpose is not to discriminate against any national group. but to discourage employers who take advantage of illegal aliens. Opponents to this bill rarely dispute the fact that some measure is needed to reduce the number of illegal aliens. However. they are not in agreement as to the method that should be employed. It is considerations of experience. pragmatics. and money which dictate that it is more efficient to place sanctions on the employer rather than to impose further duties on immigration officials. Certainly. the role of immigration specialists is important and will continue to play a critical part in the detection and apprehension of illegal immigrants. But experience has proven that foreign nationals are getting through. The Immigration and Naturalization ServiceINSreported that the great majority88 percentof illegal aliens apprehended in fiscal year 1974 entered the country without inspection. Only 12 percent violated their status after legal entry. In most cases. these persons are from bordering countries and have successfully escaped border detection. One solution might be to eradicate the problem by requiring huge new appropriations for border patrols and detection mechanisms. However. the proposed amendment would also serve as a deterrent but at no additional cost-
Identified stereotypes
Illegal aliens are drawn to the country primarily because of economic opportunities.
Keywords matched
Immigration illegal alien illegal immigrants Naturalization immigration immigrants border patrol deportation illegal aliens Illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural Other

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
—
Speech ID
940236538
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →