Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940226072

Mr. President. last Wednesday. the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously reversed a California court decision holding a California law prohibiting the employment of illegal aliens unconstitutional. The California law read as follows: Section 2805 of the California Labor Code: (a) No employer shall knowingly employ an alien who is not entitled to lawful residence in the United States if such employment would have an adverse effect on lawful resident workers. (b) A person found guilty of violation of subdivision (a) is punishable by a fine of not less than two hundred dollars ($200.000) nor more than five hundred dollars ($500.000) for each offense. (c) The foregoing provisions shall not be a bar to civil action against the employer upon a violation of subdivision (a). The substance of the Courts decision is basically threefold: First. Only Congress has jurisdiction of immigration matters. but merely because a State statute deals with aliens does not mean it confronts congressional immigration jurisdiction. Second. It is within a States police power to regulate the employment relationship and Congress in enacting immigration laws has not manifested an intent to exclusively preempt States from legislation affecting the employment of illegal aliens. Third. A California law prohibiting employers from hiring illegal aliens is. therefore. not unconstitutional on its face and it is for California courts to construe the law and determine whether the law as applied would conflict with Federal immigration laws or regulations. It should be pointed out that while the Courts decision might open the way for States to deal affirmatively with the matter of illegal alien employment. it does nothing to diminish the responsibility of Congress to come to grips with this problem now. Indeed. States are going to have a supremely difficult time if they try to limit the incidence of illegal alien employment without Federal help. In the first instance. States have no way of determining who illegal aliens are. Those not entitled to employment have that status by virtue of Federal not State laws. When such laws are violated by aliens the U.S. Government has the services of the Immigration and Naturalization Service to locate and apprehend them. In turn. INS utilizes the services of other Federal agencies such as the Social Security Administration in their search for illegal aliens. Further. INS itself has a vast store of information they have collected over the years on literally millions of aliens who have attempted to thwart our immigration laws. many of whom are repeated offenders. How a State is going to locate those not entitled to employment within its borders and prosecute employers for hiring them without any of these resources is beyond my comprehension. Last year I introduced legislation that proposed a partnership between the Federal Government and employers for the purpose of finding those aliens illegally employed in this country at the present time and discouraging such employment in the future. S. 1928 prohibits the hiring of illegal aliens but recognizes the limited role that employers. like States. can assume in assisting the Federal Government in carrying out this objective. Under this legislation employers are entitled to use a form. which. when completed at the time of hiring an employee. puts the Government on notice as to whether that person might not be entitled to employment. Furnishing employers with such a simple and expedient means of satisfying their responsibility not to hire illegal aliens has the additional benefit of significantly reducing the likelihood of discrimination against employees who. because of appearances or language. might appear to be illegal aliens. Legislation to prohibit the employment of illegal aliens must call for action by the Federal Government to be effective. Determining who is illegal and sending them home is a job only the Federal Government can do. States and employers can help. but illegal aliens are on the job to stay until Congress decides to do something about it.
Keywords matched
illegal alien Immigration Naturalization immigration illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
ROBERT PACKWOOD
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
OR
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
940226072
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →