Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940225697

Speaker. in a decision handed down yesterday. DeCanas against Bica. the U.S. Supreme Court held that a State can constitutionally legislate prohibitions on the employment of illegal aliens. Although the decision raises some question as to the deshability of diverse State laws on the subject as opposed to a uniform Federal approach to the illegal alien problem as contained in H.R. 8713 which has been favorably reported by the Judiciary Committee. the case does indicate that the State of California has a strong governmental interest in protecting the job security of its residents. In the opinion delivered for a unanimous Court. Justice Brennan described the nature of the illegal alien problem as follows: Employment of illegal aliens in time of high unemployment deprives citizens and legally admitted aliens of Jobs. acceptance by illegal aliens of jobs on substandard terms as to wages and working conditions can seriously depress wage scales and working conditions of citizens and legally admitted aliens. and employment of illegal aliens under such conditions can diminish the effectiveness of labor unions. These local problems axe particularly acute in California in light of the significant influx into that State of illegal aliens from neighboring Mexico. The Court also pointed out that the employment of illegal aliens in California has had a deleterious effect on the States economy and on the efforts of that State to protect its "fiscal interests and lawfully resident labor force." The Courts views on the scope of this problem are entirely consistent with the findings of my Subcommittee on Immigration. Citizenship. and International Law as a result of 3 years of extensive hearings on the subject. The Supreme Court also discussed the illegal alien problem at length in the case of BrignoniPonce which was rendered last June. In that case. the Court described the magnitude of the problem in the following manner: Whatever the number. these aliens create significant economic and social problems. competing with citizens and legal resident aliens for jobs. and generating extra demand for social services. The aliens themselves are vulnerable to exploitation because they cannot complain of substandard working conditions without risking deportation. In a concurring opinion in Brignoni. Justices White and Blackmun noted the ineffectiveness of current Federal efforts to intercept the "millions of aliens who enter and remain illegally in this country." and added that: Perhaps the Judiciary should not strain to accommodate the requirements of the Fourth amendment to the needs of a system which at best can demonstrate only minimal effectiveness as long as it Is lawful for business firms and others to employ aliens who are illegally in this country. Consequently. the need for legislation to control the illegal alien problem has been recognized by all three branches of Government. and I am hopeful that H.R. 8713 which represents a reasonable and humane approach to the problem will be enacted into law during the 94th Congress.
Identified stereotypes
Illegal aliens depress wage scales and working conditions.
Keywords matched
illegal alien Immigration deportation illegal aliens

Classification

Also mentioned
naturalized citizens
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural Security threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
—
Speech ID
940225697
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →