Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940207268

Mr. Chairman. the amendment I have offered would amend the committeereported bill to provide that school districts would be reimbursed for the actual costs which they have incurred in providing the necessary supplementary educational services for Indochina refugee children as well as to reimburse districts for the additional basic costs which can be directly attributod to the presence in the school district of refugee children. including the provision of additional classroom teachers and supplies where warranted. I might say here that the gentlewoman from Hawaii is saying that it would take 40.000 pieces of paper to take care of the 40.000 children. That just would not be true because as of January 15 there were only 1.400 of the 16.000 school districts that indicated the presence of refugee children. which would mean that 1.400 pieces of paper would have to be submitted. As I said in my earlier statement. I do not object to actually reimbursing school districts for the costs they may not have planned on last spring when they adoped their budgets for this current school year. The supporters of the bill before us argue that the refugees are highly concentrated in a few States. That point ignores the fact that although they may be in a few States they are spread out without those States and within those school districts to a considerable degree. I would draw your attention on that point to the chart on page 15 of the committee report. Far less than 10 percent of the school districts in the country have refugee children. As of December 1. only 1.400 out of 16.000 school districts had indicated the presence of refugee children. That is about 5 percent of the national total. Of the districts which do have refugee children. 80 percent have fewer than 21. Within those school districts six out of seven school buildings have fewer than 11 refugee children. and Mr. Chairman. 85 percent of the schools have fewer than 10 refugee children in them. What that means is that in the typical situation a classroom has had the addition of perhaps one refugee child. Since enrollments in elementary and secondary schools have been falling nationally. it is likely that the school district already had some extra desks so that the presence of that one child in each of several classrooms did not cause the addition of new teaching staff or the construction of a new building. In most districts all that has been done and all that needs to be done is to provide some special assistance in the form of language training and some special materials to assist these students in becoming integrated into the U.S. educational system. Supporters of this bill argue that Federal civil rights regulations require full bilingual education be provided these students. That is not true. The directive from the Office for Civil Rights in HEW regarding bilingual education contains an explicit statement exempting school districts with a substantial number of Indochinese refugees from the requirements of bilingual education. The proponents of this language argue that the States incurred additional costs because of the presence of these students. My amendment would leave intact the State entitlement concept provided in the committee bill and would provide that payments received under this act be distributed between the State and the local school district in proportion to their contribution to meeting these costs.
Keywords matched
refugee refugees

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALBERT QUIE
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
MN
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
940207268
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →