Session #94 · 1975–77

Speech #940159489

Texas. Chicago. and New York. The Illinois Legislative Investigating Commission calculated that "in fiscal year 1971. $75. million. was taken from the Illinois labor market by illegal Mexican aliens who held jobs which could easily be held by -American citizens and legal aliens." In addition to displacing Americans for jobs. it is also alleged that the illegal aliens contribute to depressing wages and impairing working conditions for workers in the lowerwage occupations. As these aliens are in the U.S. illegally. they will often work at lower wages. for longer hours. and under worse conditions than American workers are allowed under the law. And as there is an almost limitless supply of illegal alien workers. many employers would prefer to hire illegal aliens rather than citizens because they can do so for substandard levels of pay. It is also widely believed that many of these aliens are placing a significant burden on public assistance and social service programs. As the economy has turned down. jobs have probably also become scarce for illegal aliens. forcing more of them to turn to welfare and unemployment compensation. In the hearings held by the House Immigration Subcommittee. the preponderance of testimony indicated that illegal aliens were participating in public assistance programs. While general information on the problem was not available. the few instances in which there were figures available support this contention. It was reported that in New York City. -the New York State Department of Labor has been identifying from 15 to 20 illegal aliens per week in the group of employable persons participating in home relief or ADC programs. The Immigration and Naturalization Service recently received a bill from a county which had provided $7 million worth of medical services to illegal aliens in 1974. NewYork City and Los Angeles have both estimated that there are 60.000 children of illegal aliens in each of their city school systems. The cost of providing this service exceeds $100 million annually for the city taxpayers. To the costs of these services must be added the costs of other municipal functions. such as the use of highways. parks. and so on. which the illegal aliens use but do not pay for. While illegal aliens avail themselves of public assistance and public services. many pay no Federal income taxes. Many employers do not bother to withhold any tax. or in many cases. the alien claims enough dependents so that no tax is withheld. There seems to be no coordination between the INS and IRS on this matter. However. in a few experimental programs. substantial amounts of back taxes have been collected. For instance. one investigator in the Los Angeles INS office initiated the collection of $1 million in back taxes. A similar program in New York was yielding from $80.000 to $100.000 per month before it was discontinued at the request of the Association of Immigration and Nationality Lawyers. Thus. with better coordination with INS. the IRS might be able to collect substantial amounts of delinquent taxes from apprehended illegal aliens. Admittedly. there are arguments that have been made against some of the facts -and statistics I have just cited. but I am .33.082 convinced on the best evidence available to me that the time has come to do something about the illegal alien problem. Therefore. I am today introducing 1 gislation which. if enacted. will help to .tcm the flow of illegal aliens into this country. The bill seeks to accomplish this roal in three ways. The first section exlicity extends the criminal penalties imposed for the use or falsification of documents used to enter the United States to the false use or falsification of border crossing cards and alien registration receipt cards. and to any documents used as evidence of authorized stay in the United States. The second section prohibits the appropriation of any Federal funds for any public or private program which provides either direct or indirect aid or assistance to any individual unless as a condition of eligibility for receiving such aid or assistance the applicant is required to show proof of U.S. citizenship or legal alien residency. It is my hope that this will reduce the number of illegal aliens receiving public assistance from the U.S. Government. Finally. the third section of the bill makes unlawful the employment or referral for employment of illegal aliens. This section requires the employer. agent of an employer. or referrer to obtain from the individual a signed form stating that he Is a U.S. citizen. an alien lawfully admitted for permanent residence. or an alien authorized by the Attorney General to accept employment. The prospective employees signature is accepted as prima facie proof that the employer. agent. or referrer made a bona fide inquiry as to the individuals status.
Identified stereotypes
Illegal aliens depress wages, impair working conditions, and burden public assistance programs.
Keywords matched
illegal alien Immigration Naturalization border crossing illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JAMES BUCKLEY
Party
C
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
940159489
Paragraph
#2
← Prev Next →