Washington. D.C. DEAR M& CHAIRMAN: This letter is in response to your request for this Commissions analysis of HR 982. now HR 8713. which makes it unlawful to knowingly employ illegal aliens. It represents this Commissions official position on HR 8713. expanding upon the staff analysis of the bill which was sent to you on July 28. 1975. Our comments herein are addressed to the bill as reported out by the full Judiciary Committee on July 30. 1975. It is the view of this Commission that the passage of HR 8713 in its present form will have a direct discriminatory effect on minority persons seeking employment. whether they are citizens or aliens authorized to work in the United States. Because there is no uniform system for accurately identifying the citizenship or alien status of all persons in this country. this difficult determination will rest solely with the employer. Faced with the threat of civil and criminal sanctions if an illegal alien is found in his or her employment. the employer will take steps to minimize the risk of hiring an alien not authorized to work. Those persons whom the employer suspects of being illegal aliens will have a greater burden of giving definitive proof of their legal status than will persons not so suspected. Because of their identifiable physical characteristics. surnames. or language patterns. minority applicants will more often be suspected of being illegal aliens than will majority group applicants. Mexican Americans. other persons of Spanish origin. and Asian Americans will be among those who will be most subjected to discrimination by passage of the bill in its present form. The stated objective of HR 8713 is to make unlawful the "knowing" employment of illegal aliens. The bill requires that in order to assess civil or criminal penalties for violations of the law the government must show that the illegal alien was knowingly hired. An initial warning citation. however. can be served on the employer without the government showing that the employer knew of the persons illegal status. Employment disIt is the opinion of this Commissions Counsel that this inconsistency results in an unclear definition of the crime of employIng an illegal alien in HR 8713. Sec. 2 states
Identified stereotypes
Minority applicants will more often be suspected of being illegal aliens than will majority group applicants because of their identifiable physical characteristics, surnames, or language patterns.