Foremost. is the immediate tragedy that a man was refused sanctuary and allowed to be brutally dragged from an American ship while her captain and crew looked on. Historically. the United States has offered to the politically oppressed people of this world the opportunity of freedom and sanctuary. It is outrageous and unmerciful that not only did we fail to meet this traditional promise. but that our own citizens actually assisted in the return of the refugee to the Soviet boat. It is monstrous that the Coast Guard should indicate that their judgment was affected by a concern over how granting asylum to seaman Simas might adversely affect their fishing conference. The American people now are rightfully asking whether fish have become more important than a mans freedom and life. as well as our countrys honor.