Session #82 · 1951–53

Speech #820077135

Certainly this bill in no wise makes it more likely that there will be illegal entrants in the United States. On the contrary. this bill goes a long way toward making it improbable that we will have the substantial numbers of illegal entrants we have had in the past. Certainly the only effect this bill will have upon the enforcement of the immigration laws will be to make the enforcement much easier than it has been in the past. because it provides a legal method whereby a Mexican can enter the United States. whereas. if you do not pass this bill. there will be no legal method whereby a Mexican can come in. yet the economic magnet of high wages on the north side of the Rio Grande as opposed to the very low wages and poor living conditions on the south side will continue to draw Mexican workers across that river just as it has during the past 100 years. If perchance additional legislation in regard to purely immigration matters is needed. the gentleman who so recently addressed you. the chairman of the Judiciary Committee. might well consider bringing in such legislation. but to condemn the Committee on Agriculture because that committee properly exercised a function which is within its jurisdiction and did not seek to extend its jurisdiction tnto a field over which the Committee on the Judiciary has unquestioned jurisdiction. seems to me to be a little unfair and uncharitable on the part of the chairman of that committee. Why blame us if the chairman of that committee does not bring in the type of immigration legislation that he wants? We are not writing immigration laws. We are amending the Agricultural Labor Act. We are not trying to change or add to or diminish existing immigration laws. In our strict endeavor to try to leave the jurisdiction of other committees to those committees. we wrote a provision in this bill which was questioned here on the floor. which provision simply says that nothing in this bill shall be construed to interfere with the powers that the Attorney General now has. The gentleman from Ohio questioned the propriety of that. We are simply saying all the way through that we are trying to provide adequate agricultural labor for this country. When we have done that the Committee on Agriculture is not concerning itself with social reforms or immigration laws or with the jurisdiction of the Attorney General of the United States. We have sought here to bring to the House legislation which would correct an obvious evil. If members of other committees feel that reforms within the jurisdiction of their respective committees are needed. let those members bring legislation out of their own committees. t7156 Let me review the circumstances that make this legislation necessary: Throughout all these years. as has already been stated. many of our farmers have used Mexican labor.
Keywords matched
immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
WILLIAM COLMER
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
MS
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
820077135
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →