Speech #760053489

The date is April 19. and I shall read from it very briefly with respect to the question the gentleman from New York propounded to me: The judicial scope of review Is narrow and similar to that now exercised In habeas corpus proceedings in all immigration cases. The court may discharge an alien from custody If as a matter of law the finding of the Secretary of Labor cannot be supportedthe court may not on a question of fact substitute its own judgment as to what disposition should be made of the case. Therefore. it does not follow that the provisions for judicial review remove the instant bill from the implications of the doctrine of the Wong Wing case. supraWhich declared similar proceedings of the law unconstitutional.